The Humble Skeptic is an investigative podcast that seeks to explore the beliefs and ideas that shape our lives. The reason we need to be skeptical is due to the fact that there are so many competing dogmas out there to choose from. To put it simply, all these different views can’t be true! In fact, this is what motivated the Apostle Paul to say, “test all things—but hold on to the good” (1Th. 5:21).

Episode 1: The Pilot
Episode 2: Is Faith Irrational?
Episode 3: Is Faith Blind?
Episode 4: Is Faith a Feeling?
Episode 5: Religion on Trial
Episode 6: Faith & Certainty
Episode 7: Faith & Proof
Episode 8: Proof of the Gospel
Episode 9: The Gospel Creed
Episode 10: Fake or Authentic?

What They’re Saying…

I just finished listening to The Humble Skeptic podcast. It’s excellent! I loved the interviews, the personal storytelling and the investigational aspect. It’s a great way to explain the “humble skeptic” concept. I also loved the artistic aspect, the use of music, etc. The broadened appeal should help to generate a wide audience.
— Brandon Kimber, director of The American Gospel documentary series

This podcast is really well done! In fact, I decided to play the first minute of the pilot episode to open up a lecture at Wheaton College on Contending for Truth in an Age of Radical Subjectivism.
— John Dickson, host of Undeceptions and author of A Doubter’s Guide to Jesus

Shane Rosenthal’s Humble Skeptic podcast is superb! I was drawn in by the subject matter and narration of the first episode and am looking forward to hearing what’s next. Humble Skepticism — what a concept!
Michael Horton, host of White Horse Inn and Westminster Seminary CA professor

What an amazing podcast this is!! It's broad in the best possible way — accessible but not insubstantial or toothless. I really like it!
— David Zahl, author of Seculosity and Low Anthropology

There are a lot of podcasts from which to choose but you only have so much time, so you need to be selective. Shane Rosenthal's The Humble Skeptic is one of the best I've ever heard. It is a breath of fresh air. Riveting. I'm subscribed and I will be supporting it. You should too.
— R. Scott Clark, host of The Heidelcast and Westminster Seminary CA professor

I loved all the twists in the investigation of the Billy Joel storyline, and I was especially impressed with how this was used to make an important point. Excellent storytelling done with a high production value — I’ll be a faithful listener!
— Doug Powell, author of The Ultimate Guide to Defend Your Faith

Shane Rosenthal's new Humble Skeptic podcast is highly informative, but also fun to listen to. This is a great resource for believers and skeptics alike!
— Adriel Sanchez, host of Core Christianity

Shane Rosenthal’s fascinating new podcast, The Humble Skeptic, aims to show that a Christianity founded solidly on evidence can boldly answer the "outsider test" for truth in religious matters. With an emphasis on eyewitness testimony, careful thinking, and common sense, it promises to be an excellent addition to the apologetics podcast menu.
— Lydia McGrew, author of Hidden in Plain View and The Eye of the Beholder

Former White Horse Inn host, Shane Rosenthal, recently ventured out on his own to create The Humble Skeptic podcast. I finally listened to the pilot episode and absolutely loved it! What, pray tell, could Shane's own father and his 50+ year old memory of Billy Joel playing in a little piano bar in LA possibly have to say about Christian apologetics? Listen to the wildly entertaining story and see for yourself!
— Jeremy Smith, founder of ReThink315

The Humble Skeptic podcast is delightful! The pilot episode centered on the Piano Man story serves as a nice illustration (and a kind of parable) of the nature of belief.
— T. David Gordon, author of Why Johnny Can’t Preach

In a world of media dominated by angry voices, Shane Rosenthal’s podcast, The Humble Skeptic, is a creative alternative where honest questions lead to engaging conversations.
— Joseph R. Miller, president of the Center for Cultural Apologetics 

The Humble Skeptic is currently ranked by Apple Podcasts as one of the top 100 shows on Religion & Spirituality

The Humble Skeptic Vision

To learn more about our plans for the future, click here. To help support this work, click here (if you’d like your donation to be tax-deductible, click here). Another way to support The Humble Skeptic is by upgrading to a paid subscription through Substack by using the green button below.

The Humble Skeptic is a listener-supported podcast. To support this work, consider becoming a paid subscriber.

Subscribe to The Humble Skeptic

Shane Rosenthal | Truth Isn't Afraid of Questions


Shane Rosenthal
Shane Rosenthal is the founder and host of The Humble Skeptic podcast. He was a co-founder of the White Horse Inn, which he produced for close to 30 years, and hosted from 2019-2021.